Does a new Supreme Court decision allow partially illicit evidence to be submitted?
Publié le :
19/01/2021
19
janvier
janv.
01
2021
A recent decision of the French Supreme Court of 25 November 2020 creates a surprising precedent on the topic of the validity of evidence that can be submitted in court.
The ruling allows evidence, deemed unlawful in regard to a law on information technology and civil liberties, to be admitted in court proceedings.
It marks an evolution of the Social Chamber's case law on the unlawfulness of evidence obtained by means of data that should have been declared to the CNIL, the French Data Protection Body.
In the case at hand, an employee (journalist) challenged his dismissal. He maintained that the evidence produced by his employer was illicit, since the files in question had not been declared to the CNIL.
The Court ruled that the unlawfulness of evidence does not systematically result in its rejection. Rather, it invites the trial judge to examine, in the context of a proportionality review, whether the infringement of the employee's personal life by such production is justified in the light of the employer's right to present evidence. It also specifies that such production must be “indispensable” and no longer merely “necessary” for the exercise of this right.
The ruling is neither entirely surprising nor shocking, in fact: it draws inspiration from the decisions of the ECHR in respect of Articles 6 and 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights. Those rulings had admitted evidence obtained at the expense of the right to privacy under Article 8 of the Convention or in breach of domestic law. This was justified on the basis of the right to a fair trial and the right to evidence.
Historique
-
Joël Grangé: restoring the image of French labour law
Publié le : 21/01/2021 21 janvier janv. 01 2021L&E GlobalAfter more than thirty years at the Paris Bar, Joël Grangé says he is still f...Source : leglobal.org
-
"Tests antigéniques en entreprise, mode d’emploi" par Stéphane Bloch et Fabien Crosnier
Publié le : 20/01/2021 20 janvier janv. 01 2021Dans les médiasChaque mois, Avosial publie une chronique pour actuEL-RH. Ce mois-ci, Stéphan...
-
"Épargne salariale - Les mesures d’épargne salariale de la loi ASAP" par Juliana Kovac et Lucy Gaudemet-Toulemonde
Publié le : 19/01/2021 19 janvier janv. 01 2021Dans les médiasPrésenté au Conseil des ministres le 5 février 2020, le projet de loi d’accél...
-
Handling the consequences of Brexit
Publié le : 19/01/2021 19 janvier janv. 01 2021NewsDecember 31, 2020 marked the end of the transition period following the Unite...
-
Does a new Supreme Court decision allow partially illicit evidence to be submitted?
Publié le : 19/01/2021 19 janvier janv. 01 2021NewsA recent decision of the French Supreme Court of 25 November 2020 creates a s...